05 čģĸįīŧ
įŦŦäēįĢ čģĸįãä¸ä¸äšåã
῏
åĨå¤ĢåŠĻã¯įĨãŽåãįãŽåã¨å
ąãĢããžã å¤ãŽãããŦä¸ããįĨæŽŋãŽå¤§æé¤ããĒãåąąéãŽäžįŠãįŽãįĨčŠãåĨä¸ããĻããã
ãéĢ夊åãŽčå ´ãĢå
æ´ĨåžĄįĨãŽå¤§įĨãŽå¤§įĨč¨ããĄãĻã夊ãããåŊããã夊äŊŋå
Ģįžä¸įĨéã˛ãĢéã˛ãžããæąãŽéŊã¯æĨåēãåŊãŽåžĄåãéĢãããã¨æ¸
ã
ããå°é˛ãŽåˇãå˛ãããįļžãŽčå°ãŽå
Ģå°æŽŋãåčĨŋãŽåŊãĢčŗããĻã¯ãããŦãšãããŽåŊãŽåžĄåãéĢãã¨ãĢãĩãŦã ãŽéŊããĒãĒãåąąãŽé ããĢ厎æąå¤ĒããįĢãĻãĻéŽãžããžãåŗã¨įã¨ãŽäēæąåžã˛įãĩįĨäŊŋæå¤ãĢ夊ãããåŊããããžãããĻããšãåąąãŽčå ´ãĢã¯įĨį´ įåãŽå°ã常įŖå
įŖãĢåžĄãã¨ãåãããįã˛ãåæšãŽéäēēčã¯äēãĩãæ´ãĒãã迍čĢæãŽį̝ãĢčŗãčŋãæĩãŋãŽé˛ãåãããįãĩå°ãæ¸
ãå¤§åžĄåŋãæãŋåĨããæãĒå¤ãĒãĢæ¤įĨåēãĢåŗãŽåžĄéãæãåĨããĻäģã¸ãžã¤ãäēãŽįąãããã¨åšŗããåŽãããčåŦãį¸čĢžã˛įã˛ãĻãããŠãĸãŗãŽæįĨãĢéã¯ãããä¸äēãŽįĨæąįæ¸
åĨãããĻãåãŗä¸ãŽå
ã¨ãĒããåĄŠã¨ãĒããčąã¨ããĒããĻã夊æ´å¤§åžĄįĨãŽå¤§įĨæĨãĢäģã¸åĨãããįã¸ãäģ°ãéĄã¯ãã°ãããŽåŽļå
ãããĻč̏ã
ãŽæäēãįŊĒįŠĸããããããæĨã
ãŽæĨåãåąãŋå¤ããĻããããļäēãĒããæ ãäēãĒããįĨč°ˇãŽæãŽéã¨ããĻ常įŖå
įŖãĢč¨ãžãįã¸ã¨įãŋįãŋįĨéĄãŋåĨããã¨įŗããä¸äēãŽå¤§įĨåŽãįã¸åš¸ã¯ã¸įã¸ãæįĨãŽåžĄé嚸ã¸ãžããžãã
ã¨įĨčŠãįĩããåēåãčĻĒååäēēéŖãæ°įŠēæ°ãåŧå¸ããšãééĨãåããã
ããĢãŽãŧã¯ããĒã¤å§Ģã坿¯ãįĒēã˛ããŊãã¨čŖåŖããããåēããäŊåĻããŽåŽļã¸åŋãŗčžŧãŋãæ˛ĸåąąãĒéģéãããããĻããĒã¤å§ĢãéŠããæåŋã財ã¯ãããŽã¨įĄčŦãĢãéŖãŗåēããĻäēã¤ãã
ããĒã¤å§Ģã¯įæ¸
åĨãįĨčŠãŽåŖ°ãĢããã¨įŽãããžããæ
ãĻãĻææ°´ãäŊŋã˛įĨæŽŋãĢį°ĄåãĒãįĨčŠãåĨä¸ããįĩã¤ãĻåžåą
éã¸å¸°ããã¯ãŠã´ãŖãŗãŧããããĸã¤ãĻããã¨ãå
ļåĻã¸įæ¸
åĨå¤ĢåŠĻãčĨãéãĢæŧããããå
ĨãæĨãã
῏
ãããĒã¤æ§ããæŠãåžĄåē§ããžãã
įåãæãæŠãããä¸šį˛žãĒäēã§åžĄåē§ããžããĒããģãã¨ããĢåžĄæéãããå´ããĻããžãã¯ã
ããĒã¤ã¯ã¯ãŠã´ãŖãŗãŧããåēãĢį´ããä¸äēå°ēåžããããäšãä¸å¯§ãĢ严æãã¤ãã
ãããã¯ããã¯åžĄä¸ģäēēæ§ãåĨĨæ§ããæŠãåžĄåē§ããžããããããä¸čŠąãĢé ããžããĻčĒ ãĢįŗč¨ŗãåžĄåē§ããžããŦã
įåãå§ĢããžãäŊãäģ°æããžããæ¤åĻã¯įĨæ§ãŽåŽļããä¸čŠąãããĻé ããŽã¯įĨæ§ã¸ãŽåžĄåĨå
Ŧã§åžĄåē§ããžããåžĄį¤ŧãįŗãããžããĻã¯å´ãĻå°ããžããäŊåæ°ãäŊŋã¯ããĢãĻãĢãĻãĢåžĄéįä¸ãããžãã
ããĒããã¤ãæéŖãåžĄåē§ããžãããč¨čãĢįã¸ãĻããĻãã¯ãĒã¨ãä¸čŠąãĢé ã¤ãĻåą
ããžããã
῏
ãįļãããĒã¤æ§ã貴åĨŗãŽãã¤ããĢãĒã¤ãããĢãŽãŧã¨ãäēãĩæšã¯ãäŊåĻã¸čĄãããžãããåžĄåãã§ãããĒãĸã
ããĒããã¤ãå¤åãåĻžãŽã¯ãŠã´ãŖãŗãŧãããčããĢãĒããį´ããããŋãĢãĒã¤ããããĢæã¤ãĻããžããã
῏
ããããå§Ģæ§ã¯åžĄåãããĒããŽã§ãããäģæãããå§ŋãčĻããĒããŽã§ããã
ããĒãããåˇĻæ§ã§åžĄåē§ããžããã
ã¨åšŗįļã¨ããĻããã
῏
ãå§Ģæ§ãä¸å¯¸ãäŧēã˛č´ãåēĻããŽã§ãããããŽįˇãŽį´ æ§ã¯åžĄåãã§åžĄåē§ããžãããã
ããĒãããã¯ããĢãŽãŧã¨įŗããžããĻããŋãã°ã¯åąąãŽæŗĨæŖãŽå˛ŠįĒãĢå°é ããã¤ãĻããžãããŽã ããåĻžããæ¨å¤åã¤ãįįåã¨äēãĩåĻå§ãĢãããŽããããæŗĨæŖãŽå˛ŠįĒãĢåããŠããããĻéãåēĻãã¨čã¸ãæĒå§ãŽé
ãĢé
ãĩããŽã嚸ã˛ãããŽããĢãŽãŧãč˛ãäģĨãĻãĄãããžãããããžãčåŖãéãããŽã§åžĄåē§ããžãããžã åŽļãĢãã¸ãčŋéį¨ãåžĄåē§ããžããŽã§ãč
šãŽæĒãäēã¨įĨããĒãããšãŦãŽéãĢãã¸ãčŋãäŊã¨ãåŊŧã¨ãįŗããĻéãããĻããããã¨čã¸ãééŖããĢãĒã¤ãĻããŽã§åžĄåē§ããžããåŽãŽåĻã¯åŽéãŽäēãåžĄå¤ĢåŠĻæ§ãĢæãĄæãåēĻãã¨åããžããããããĢãŽãŧãäŊã¨äēã¤ãĻãå´ãéĸããĒããŽã§įŗä¸ããæŠäŧãåžããĢåą
ããžãããåžĄå¤ĢåŠĻæ§ã¯åĻžãæĒãįˇãéŖããĻããã¨ããããčãŋã§åžĄåē§ããžããããåŗãŽãããĒæŦĄįŦŦã§åžĄåē§ããžãããäŊååŽãããéĄã˛įŗããžãã
῏
ããããĢããåžåŽļã¸ãč¨ĒããĢãĒã¤ãæããåĻãĒå¤ĢåŠĻã ã¨æã¤ãĻåą
ãžããããŠãããĻããžãã貴åĨŗãŽãããĒæˇåĨŗã¨æŗĨæŖéĸãŽä¸åééã¨åžĄå¤ĢåŠĻã§æ
čĄããããŽãããžãã¤ããâĻâĻæ¨éĻŦåļããĻįŗåĨŗãåãįŖããããĒ芹ã âĻâĻã¨äēã¤ãĻåŽļå
ã¨åããĻããåĻã§åžĄåē§ããžããã¤ãĸããčããĻåŽåŋč´ããžãããåŊŧãŽããĢãŽãŧã¯ãææŠæ¤åĻã¸ã¯å¸°ã¤ãĻæĨãžããžãããããåžã
å¤ĢåŠĻããåŽ
čŋéã¤ãĻä¸ããžãããåžĄåŽåŋãĒãããžãã
ããĒãåĻäŊããĻåãããŽããĢãŽãŧãæ¤åĻã¸å¸°ããĒããŽã§ããã貴æšãĢéã¤ãĻé ãã°ããŽãããĒåąéēãĒč
ãĢééŖããĢãĒãããĢããããä¸åŽåŋã§ãããåŊŧã¯åäŊãããããŦäēã§ãč´ãããŽã§åžĄåē§ããžããã
῏
ãã¨ãŧãåŊŧã¯æ¨å¤æˇąæ´ãĢãæå
ãŽæĸå
ĩčĄãåŽļãĢčĻéĸé åˇžã§æ´ãčžŧãŋãåŽļæãããŗį¸ããééãæŽããåĨĒã˛ã¨ãéãåēãéį̝ãéåŖãŽæˇąä翏ãĢčŊãĄčžŧãŋãããĩããĩã¨é¨ãã§åą
ã¤ãæãä¸å¯įĒãčĻäģãåēããä翏ããåŧãä¸ãåŊŧãåŧį¸ã¤ãĻãæĸå
ĩčĄãŽåŽļãĢãã¤ãĒãã§ããããã§åžĄåē§ããžããäģãŽå
ä¸å¯įĒãããã訴ã¸ãĻåããžããã
ããĒã¤ã¯ããã¯ãĒãäšãã
ãã¨ãŧãäŊã¨ããĸæĒãåĨ´ã§åžĄåē§ããžããĒãåŋŊãĄå¤ŠįŊ°ãå ąãĩãĻæĨãĻåžã¨åžæãĢæˇąä翏ãĢéĨčžŧãã ãŽã§åžĄåē§ããžãããįļãäšãæŗĨæŖã¨ã¯äēã¸ãæ¤åąąéĒããŋãã°ã¯č°ˇããæ¤åĻčŋéã¤ãĻæĨãĻãããįˇãčĻæ¨ãĻãĻãã荺ãĢãčĄããžããŦãããä¸įŽäŧã¯ããĻä¸ãããžããŦããåŊŧãĢčĒ ãŽéãčĒŦãčãããĻããåēĻãåžĄåē§ããžããããããã¨ãæãŽæã§åžĄææãĒãããŽãĒãæ¯éã¯åžĄåē§ããžããŦã
῏
ãæ¤æã¯ä¸å䏿¸åžĄåē§ããžããããäŊããä¸äēæãŽäŋĄč
ã§ãäēēéãčŖãã¨äēãĩäēãč´ããžããŦãčĒ ãŽéãčĒŦãčãããĻãããŽæå¤ããžã§éãčŋŊæžããäēãĢãĒã¤ãĻåą
ããžãã嚸ã˛å§Ģæ§ãåžĄč¨æãä¸ã¸ãĻä¸ããäēãĒããåŊŧãæēčļŗããã§ãããįļãã°ããã¸éŖãåããžãããã
ããĒããã¤ããéĒéäšãããéĄã¸ãã°įĩæ§ã§åžĄåē§ããžããã
῏
ãįļãã°ããããä¸å¯įĒãĢįŗäģããæ¤åĻã¸åŧåŧĩã¤ãĻåããžãããæĢããåž
ãĄä¸ããã
ã¨äēã˛äšãčļŗæŠãĢåēã§ãĻčĄãã
įåå§Ģãå¤ĢãŽåžãĢåžã˛čģŊãįŽį¤ŧãæŊãäšãåžåą
éã¸ã¨å¸°ãčĄãããã¨ãĢæŽã¤ãããĒã¤å§Ģã¯æĒäēēã¨ã¯äēã˛äšããäŊåĻã¨ããĒããĢæããåŦããåĻäŊãããĻåŊŧãŽåŋãæšããããã¨ãã¯ãŠã´ãŖãŗãŧããåŧžãäšãįĨãĢįĨã¤ãĻããã
ã夊ã¨å°ã¨ãŽããŽä¸ãĢįãã¨ãįããįŠã¯æ˛ĸãããŠ
įĨãŽåŊĸãĢé ãããäēēã¯éãŽåéãŽåŽŽã¨äēãĩ
ããäēēįãŽčĄčˇ¯ãå°ãŦãã°åˇįŦãŽæ°´ãŽæĩããåĻã
æå¤ãĢå¤ãčĄãæĩŽãã¤æ˛ãŋã¤åãã¤čģĸãŗã¤åčĩˇãã¤
äēēįãŽæŗĸãæ¸ĄãčĄãåããæĒãããæŧãĒãšãĻ
äŊããäēēã¯įĨãŽåžĄåãĒããšãæĨã¯æ˛ĸãããŠ
äēēãŽåŽãæ ãã¨ãææĨãéãäēēããã¯
äēēãĢããĻäēēãĢéãäēēãŽįŽįãįŖãĒãã
ããĢãŽãŧã ã¨ãĻįãã¤ããĻãŽįäēēãĢã¯éããã
æĩŽä¸ãŽæŗĸãĢčĨ˛ã¯ããĻčããåĢããįäēēãŽ
įž¤ãĢå
ĨãããäēãĒããäēēãŽæ
ã¯åŊŧãįĨã
åžãæ
ã˛ãĻåąąéĒãæ¤åĻčŋéãæĨããã¯
æã¨ã¯äēã¸ãŠä¸įãŽčĒ åŋãŽčŧãããã°ãã
ãšãŦãŽæ¸¯ãĢčŗããĒã°æĒããåŋãæšããĻ
įäēēãĢãĒããã¨čĒã˛ããããŽčãŽæ šãŽäšžãŦéãĢ
ãĸãŊãããžããäēēãŽåãŽåŽļãĢåŋãŗãĻéģéã
įãåŋã¯äŊäēããåžčēĢãæãĩãããŽäŊã
éģéãŽåŽãåĨĒã˛ã¨ãåžæåŋã財ã¯ãã¨ã
æ¨ããããžããŽåŋããĒä¸äēæãŽå¤§åžĄįĨ
åŊŧãåŋãĢå
æãå°į
§ãéããįæã
æŠãįäēēãŽįž¤ãĢå
ĨãįããĻæ¤ä¸ãŽį¨ãĢįĢãĄ
æģããĻã¯įĨãŽå¸¸äš
ãĢãããžãåŊãĢä¸ãčĄã
æ°¸äš
ãŽįåŊãæĨŊãããĢéããįã¸æįĨ
ããĢãŽãŧãŽįˇãŽåãĢį¸äģŖãããĒã¤ãŽå§Ģãįåŋã
ãããĻįĨéĄãŋåĨãããæįĨã
ã
æŠé ŧãåãįã¸æŠé ŧãåãįã¸ã
ãããæã¸æäēēãŽåŖ°ãŦã¤ãŦã¤ã¨ããĢãŽãŧãåŧįĢãĻäšãéåŖãĢéã¤ãĻæĨãã
ããĢãŽãŧã¯åēãŽæ¤čžŧãŽä¸ãĢ蚲ãŋäšãããĒã¤å§ĢãĢåã¯ãéĄãĒãã¨ãéĄããåžãããčŊæļããĻãããããĒã¤å§Ģã¯åēä¸é§ãįŠŋããããĢããĢã¨å
ļå´ãĢãããæåããĻäēã¤ä¸ã¤åŊŧãŽé ãčģŊãæãĄäšããæļãŽåŖ°ãåŧĩãä¸ããĻã
ããããããĢãŽãŧããžããåããžã¯ãåĻžãĢæšåŋããã¨äēã¤ãäēã¯ãšããĢãĒåã ã¤ããŽã§ãããäŊã¨äēãĩãããžããäēããĒãããžãããä¸ãŽä¸ãĢįēãæĨã¯æ˛ĸåąąãããĢãå¤é°ãĢį´ããĻäēēæ§ãŽåŽļãĢåŋãŗå
ĨãæĒčįĄéãĢãäēēãæŦãä¸ãåãæåĨãä¸ĻãšįĢãĻãæąãčã§č˛¯ã¸ãéãįããã¨ã¯åŽãĢįˇåãŽéĸæąããäŊã¨äēãĩæĒéã貴æšãĢé
ã¤ããŽã§ãããåĻžã¯č˛´æšãŽãããĒæšã¨äžäģ¤ä¸æĨã§ãééŖããĢãĒã¤ããŽãæŽåŋĩã§åžĄåē§ããžããįļãåĻžã貴æšãĢãæãįŗããã°ãĒããŦäēãåžĄåē§ããžããä¸äēæãŽããĻãĒãŋãŗã§ããäšãåĻäŊãããĻããŽå˛ŠįĒããčēĢãéããã¨ãäģčŋåŋãĢããĒãäēãäēã¤ãĻ貴æšãé¨ã¤ãĻããžãããæąēããĻį§ã¯č˛´æšãĢææ
ããĻã¯ããžããŦãč
šãŽåēããããã°ãããã§ããã§å ĒããĒããŽã§ãããįļãäšãããšãŦãŽéã¸å¸°ããžã§č˛´æšãããžãåŠį¨ããã¨æã¤ãį§ãŽįŊĒãåšžéãĢããčŠĢãč´ããžãããåããžãæ¤æã¸æĨãĻčĩ¤æĨããããŽããã¤ãããĒį§ããã¤ããããį§ãæĒããŽã§ãããŠããåĒäģéãåŋãæšããĻįäēēéãĢãĒã¤ãĻä¸ãããžãããããĻåãšãŦãŽéãŽæšã¸ã§ããčļããĢãĒããžãããããŠããåžåŽļã¸č¨ĒåããĻä¸ããããæ¤æã¯ä¸äēæãŽäŋĄč
ã§ãäēēãŽããæšč¨ąãã ãã貴æšãŽįŊĒã訹ããĻä¸ããããã§ãããããĩãĸæŠããŠã¤ãã¸ããã§ãĒãããžããåŋ
ãåŋ
ãéã§æĒãäēããĒãã¤ãĄããããžããŦããããã¯å°ã訹ãã§ãã莝éãĢäŊŋã¤ãĻä¸ããã
ã¨čĨãĢį¸Ģã˛ããã§ãã¤ãå°å¤ã䏿ã¨ãåēãããĢãŽãŧãŽæãĢæģãĸããŋããåˇĻæ§ãĒããã¨äēã˛ã¤ã¤ãããããæŗŖããäšãä¸ã¸ãããåžåą
éã¸ã¨å¸°ãčĄããæäēēã¯ã ãŠã ãŠã¨ããĢãŽãŧãŽå¨å˛ãã¨ããžããéįĢšæã¤ãĻ大å°ãåŠãäšãã
ããĩãĸįĢãĻã帰ãã
ã¨åžããã¤ããĻãæå¤ãããããĻéãčĄãã
῏
åĨå¤ĢåŠĻã¯ã¤ãã¨č¸ãæĢã§ä¸ããåãŗããĒã¤å§ĢãŽåą
éãĢå
ĨãæĨãã
῏
ãããĒã¤æ§ã貴åĨŗãŽčĻä¸ãããåŋãå´ãĢčããĻããåžã
äēäēēã¯åŋãŽåēããæŗŖããããžããããããŽåžĄč¨æãĢãã¤ãĻããĢãŽãŧãæšåŋããã§åžĄåē§ããžããã
ããĒããã¤čĒ ãĢčĩ¤éĸãŽčŗãã§åžĄåē§ããžããããĢãŽãŧããžããããŽãããĒãļããĢãĒã¤ããŽãããã¨ãč¨ãã°į§ãæĒããŽã§åžĄåē§ããžããã館ãĢčŋˇæãæããĻ᏿¸ãŋãžããŦãįŠ´ã§ãããã°ãããčžŧãŋåēĻããããĒæ°åãč´ããžãã
įåãäŊäģ°æããžããããĒã¤æ§ã貴åĨŗãŽįĢå ´ã¨ããĻã¯ãæã¨å ´åãĢãã¤ãĻãããĢãŽãŧãé¨ããĒãããŽãæĸããåžãžããŦãäŊäēãįįĨæ§ãŽãĒããæĨã§åžĄåē§ããžããįļãäšã夊įåã¨äēãĩåĨ´ãéä¸ãĢåž
ãĄåãããŠããĒäēãããããįĨããžããŦãããäē䏿ĨéįãĒãã¤ãĻã帰ããĒãã¤ããåŽå
¨ã§åžĄåē§ããžãããããŽæã¯ãåąåŧˇãĒæäēēãäēä¸äēēã¤ããĻéãããžãããåžĄåŽåŋä¸ããã
ããĒãäŊããäŊãžã§ããä¸čŠąãĢãĒããžããĻčĒ ãĢæéŖãåžĄåē§ããžããäŊååŽãããéĄã˛įŗããžãã
īŧ大æŖä¸åãģä¸ä¸ãģ䏿§äšãģäē䏿ŧįĨĨæé¤¨åæéå
é˛īŧ
No.: 3087